Document risk assessments or carry them out systematically?

Safexpert vs. Word

Word is a familiar and flexible tool for creating documents. Safexpert was specifically developed for the structured execution and documentation of risk assessments, as well as their integration into the CE process.

A risk assessment is more than just a document

A risk assessment is more than just the finished document. Hazards, risks, measures, standards and changes are interconnected and need to be processed in a traceable manner as part of the overall process.

This is where a key difference between a document tool such as Word and specialised software such as Safexpert becomes apparent: It is not only the result that is documented – the information and interrelationships within the risk assessment are also processed in a structured way.

The information is interconnected.
This turns documentation into a structured process.

Word can be the right solution

Word is well established in many companies, can be used flexibly, and is a pragmatic solution for individual or manageable risk assessments.

Familiar
Easy to access for most users

Flexible
Freely combine text, tables, images and individual content

Quickly available
Already available in many companies

Documentation
Results can be compiled clearly and traceably in a single document

What happens when the machine changes?

If changes are made to a machine during or after the design process, this can affect the risk assessment: A hazard may be affected, a risk may need to be reassessed, a protective measure may need to be adapted, or a reference to a standard may need to be reviewed.

The more interdependencies a risk assessment has, the less it is about creating a document – and the more it is about managing a process.

Machine is modified
Is a hazard affected?
Does the risk need to be reassessed?
Does a protective measure need to be adapted?
Which standards are affected?
Which documentation needs to be updated?

The more interdependencies a risk assessment has, the less it is about creating a document – and the more it is about managing a process.

Word and Safexpert take different approaches

Word supports the creation and individual design of documents. Safexpert supports the systematic processing of risk assessments and the structured linking of relevant information within the CE process.

WordSafexpert
MethodologyWord About templates and your own process organisationSafexpertSystematically in accordance with the underlying methodology
Hazards and risksWordWithin the document structureSafexpertRecorded in a structured manner and linked to one another
Measures and standardsWordVia the document’s own organisationSafexpertLinked in a structured manner
ReuseWordAbout documents and templatesSafexpertSystematically reusable
CE processWordMust be carried out at an organisational level SafexpertIntegrated within a shared project context

When to Use Word – and When Safexpert Adds Value

The right tool is not determined solely by the number of pages or the size of the company. What matters is how complex, recurring and interconnected the risk assessment process is.

Word can be a suitable choice when …

Green Checkmark IconRisk assessments are created only occasionally
Green Checkmark IconThe people creating the risk assessments have a high level of expertise and extensive experience
Green Checkmark IconProducts and projects are manageable
Green Checkmark IconOnly a few people are involved
Green Checkmark IconLittle reuse of existing content is required
Green Checkmark IconChanges are infrequent

Safexpert offers advantages when …

Green Checkmark IconRisk assessments are created regularly
Green Checkmark IconSimilar products or variants are recurring
Green Checkmark IconKnowledge and content need to be reused
Green Checkmark IconSeveral people work together
Green Checkmark IconStandards and measures need to be managed systematically
Green Checkmark IconThe risk assessment is part of a broader CE process

Get to know Safexpert

Would you like to find out whether Safexpert is the right fit for your process? Get to know Safexpert and discover how structured risk assessments work with Safexpert.

Frequently asked questions about Safexpert and Word

Yes. In principle, a risk assessment can be created and documented using Word. What matters is not the software used, but that the risk assessment is carried out and documented in a methodologically appropriate, traceable and complete manner.

For individual or manageable risk assessments, Word can therefore be a practical solution. This requires the people carrying out the risk assessment to have a high level of expertise. If companies need more guidance throughout the process and want to strengthen legal certainty, a professional tool can provide additional support. This also applies when risk assessments are created, updated or reused across multiple projects on a regular basis.

Word can be suitable for risk assessments, particularly for individual or manageable projects carried out by experienced professionals. The program offers flexible options for bringing together text, tables, images and other information in a single document.

The challenge lies less in creating the document itself and more in managing the technical interrelationships and representing the regulatory and standards-related processes behind it. When dealing with numerous hazards, measures, standards, variants or recurring projects, specialised software can offer advantages.

Word is primarily a tool for creating and editing documents. Safexpert is specialised software for the structured execution and documentation of risk assessments and their integration into the CE process.

The key difference is therefore not just the finished document, but how the information within a risk assessment is processed, structured and interconnected.

Compared to a standard Word template, Safexpert offers two key advantages: On the one hand, Safexpert provides a clearly defined process, supported by additional plausibility checks that can help increase legal certainty. On the other hand, Safexpert is particularly helpful for recurring risk assessments and promotes greater standardisation across the company.

This makes it possible to organise the risk assessment process more systematically than when information is managed exclusively through individual documents and templates.

A Word template can be sufficient when very simple risk assessments are created only occasionally, products and projects are manageable, and only a few people are involved. A document-based solution can also be practical when little content needs to be reused and changes are infrequent.

As the number of projects, variants, hazards, measures or people involved increases, the need for a more structured solution may also grow.

Specialised risk assessment software can be useful when risk assessments are carried out regularly and large amounts of information need to be managed across multiple projects. Typical factors include recurring products or variants, numerous hazards and measures, multiple users, extensive references to standards, or frequent changes.

Specialised software can also offer advantages over a document-based solution when the risk assessment is closely linked to other tasks within the CE process.

Safexpert is particularly suitable for companies that value a structured approach to risk assessments, the reuse of information, and the integration of risk assessments into the CE process.

What matters is less the size of the company than the complexity, frequency and interconnectedness of its processes.